How To Prepare A Strong Counter Proposal

Congratulations! You have received a job offer and the employer wants you to decide right away if you are going to accept. Now what should you do?

Don’t get in a rush

The most important thing to remember is that you do not have to accept the employer’s offer immediately. In fact, it is better if you do not give an answer right away, instead asking for some time to review the offer in more detail. Most employers will accommodate this request, as long as you don’t ask for a review period that is too lengthy. Depending on the job position you have been offered, it is generally acceptable to ask for two or three days after you receive a written offer to make your decision.

Get it in writing

In order to properly and thoroughly review a job offer, you need to get it in writing. Most employers provide a written offer as a matter of practice, but be sure to ask for one just in case. Once you have the offer in hand read it carefully to thoroughly understand all of the details. Pay attention to salary as a main component, but also note other aspects such as medical/dental benefits, bonus or incentive pay, vacation time, relocation expenses, 401K and retirement program, etc.

Do your homework

With the written offer in place you can do some research on whichever aspects of the offer you would like to counter. The most common item countered is salary, so take the time to learn more about the employer, the location, and the industry. Research comparable positions and their salary ranges to determine if the salary in the offer is reasonable and appropriate. Also, pay attention to your own skills and attributes, and how you will benefit the employer. If you have a great deal of experience and expertise you will likely be in a better position to ask for a higher salary than if you are new to the profession or career field.

Present your counter proposal

When you present your counter proposal, you should do so simultaneously in writing and verbally. The best case is to have a face-to-face discussion with the employer where you can present your case and have a productive back and forth discussion. If distance or other obstacles prevent this, the next best option is to hold the discussion via telephone, making sure both you and the employer have a written copy of the counter proposal in hand during the discussion.

As you make your case for the counter proposal, focus on the positive. Note the things you admire and respect about the employer, and talk about the immediate benefits you will bring to the position. Use information gathered during your research to support your proposed changes.

The outcome

When you choose to present a counter proposal, there are three things that can happen:

  • Your counter proposal is accepted
  • The employer will offer a counter proposal back
  • The employer will reject your counter proposal, making it clear that their original offer is the maximum they will propose

If your counter proposal is accepted, or if the employer counters back, you will need to make a final decision to accept or reject the position. If, however, your counter proposal is rejected completely then you have an even more difficult decision to make.

With your counter proposal effectively off the table, you are faced with either accepting or rejecting the original offer. This can be very difficult, as rejecting the original offer means walking away from a job and accepting the original offer means taking something less than what you feel you are truly worth. The choice you make really depends on your personal circumstances, so consider your options carefully before rendering a final decision.

« « Previous PostHow To Get The Salary You Want In A Competitive Market | Next PostKnow Your Market Value » »


What Our Clients Say


After my resume was complete I was getting interviews for jobs I would never have been able to get otherwise.

Brian Clayton. West Palm Beach, Florida


It was quite possibly one of the best decisions I have ever made. I jumped up 15,000 dollars from my last job.

Lee Stone, Waynesboro, Virginia


The communication was excellent and more importantly the results were.

Bryce Bregen, Phoenix, Arizona


If you are looking for a resume, get it written by this service. They are so professional, their turnaround was great. You need this, you need this in your life.

Bob Smith, Frankfurt, Atlanta


These are the results that I wanted but could not get on my own. I recommend Ignite Resumes for anyone who is tired waiting around for the results that they want.

Greg Gilbert, Kerrvile, Texas


I have gotten a good job and made more money. So they are highly recommended by me and I have already referred several friends to them.

Mike Crawford, Akron, Westerville, Ohio


It was in 2 months after my email to Ignite Resumes I was in my dream job. Thank you. That was the best email I ever sent.

Glorianna Maenner, Downingtown, Pennsylvania


I got the job I wanted with a 10k increase. After getting the job I spoke to Human Resources person and she told me that I had a fantastic resume how well written it was.

Anthony Rafferty, Florence, New Jersey.


Their turnaround is quick and easy and also they even give you a solid cover letter and follow up thank you letter

Charlotte Bethune-Fisher, Wantagh, New York


It came out looking absolutely fabulous. It was very professional, very efficient. They knew all the right buzzwords to get attention.

Cindy A. Mignault, Abington, Masschusetts